BVA application delayed: an action for failure to act in a Spätaussiedler case
Legal sources checked in the original article: 6 October 2026.
If Germany’s Federal Office of Administration (BVA) takes a long time to decide, an action for failure to act—Untätigkeitsklage—may be available before the administrative court under section 75 VwGO. It is normally brought no earlier than three months after the relevant application or administrative objection. The passing of that period does not require the BVA to issue a positive decision and does not mean a court will immediately conclude the case.
First establish which decision is outstanding: the admission decision (Aufnahmebescheid) before relocation, or the certificate under section 15 BVFG after arrival in Germany. Then review the start of the relevant procedure, documents and the authority’s explanations. This guide explains what to prepare and when to discuss judicial protection with a German lawyer.
Which BVA document are you waiting for?
The admission decision before relocation
An Aufnahmebescheid is the admission decision in the Spätaussiedler procedure for eligible ethnic German resettlers. Normally, an applicant requests it while living in the area of origin covered by the legislation. Specific statutory exceptions exist, so a person already in Germany needs a separate assessment. The BVA conducts the procedure and issues the decision. The legal bases are section 27 BVFG and section 28 BVFG.
To assess a delay, gather the admission application, evidence of receipt by the BVA, details of relatives included and all subsequent correspondence. The case reference, or Aktenzeichen, helps locate the file. On its own, it does not establish precisely what was requested or whether the necessary evidence is complete.
The certificate after Friedland
After entry and registration in Friedland, a different document is involved: the certificate under section 15 BVFG. According to the official service description, the certification procedure begins after the admission procedure in Friedland. A separate application is not required for ordinary issuance; the certificate is posted to the person’s residence. This describes the normal process, not a guaranteed completion date for your case. Official service description for the Spätaussiedler certificate.
The BVA issues the certificate. Subsection 1 concerns confirmation of Spätaussiedler status; subsection 2 concerns the spouse or descendant included in the admission decision. Saying “we are waiting for our paragraph” is therefore not specific enough. Identify the document and legal basis for each family member. Section 15 BVFG.
The common labels “section 4”, “section 7” and “section 8” do not describe three equivalent certificates. Section 8 primarily governs allocation and allows certain relatives who do not meet section 7(2) to be allocated together with the family. Participation in that allocation does not itself create an entitlement to a certificate under section 15(2). Section 8 BVFG.
What does the three-month rule mean?
Section 75 VwGO concerns an application or administrative objection that has not been decided within a reasonable period without sufficient justification. An action is normally possible after three months; special circumstances may justify an earlier action. If there is sufficient justification for the delay, the court stays proceedings for a period it sets, which may be extended. Section 75 VwGO.
The practical question is whether your documents and circumstances support judicial protection now. Two families may have waited equally long but have very different files. One may have answered every request months ago, while the other still needs to establish descent or resolve substantial contradictions.
Keep any message saying that the case is being processed. Such a message does not explain the actual obstacle to a decision. More specific information is needed, to the extent the authority is permitted to disclose it.

From which date should the waiting period be calculated?
For an admission decision, establish when the BVA received the relevant application and exactly what it requested. The date a reference number was allocated may differ from the receipt date. A postal receipt without a copy of the contents does not answer every question either.
Completeness can be legally significant. In its order of 2 December 2025, the Federal Administrative Court emphasised the need for a prior application containing the information and documents necessary for a decision. That judgment concerned another administrative procedure and is not a ready-made answer for every BVFG case. It does, however, show the risk of assuming that any letter sent three months ago is enough. BVerwG, 1 B 15.25, paragraph 6.
For a delayed certificate after Friedland, the old admission application date cannot simply be reused. Nor is the date of entry automatically the legally relevant starting point. Because ordinary certification is initiated by the authority, a fresh separate application should not be presented as mandatory in every case.
A lawyer examines the commencement of the section 15 procedure, Friedland registration, notification of the residential address and the precise decision outstanding. A written request to issue a specified certificate may clarify the position, but it is not automatically the only possible starting date. On initiation by the authority, see also BVerwG, 1 B 132.17, paragraphs 7–9.
A new request for evidence does not automatically erase all prior waiting time. Distinguish essential gaps in the original application, clarification of information already provided and a request for a new decision. Record every request and every complete response with its date.
Which possible causes of delay should you check?
- Did the latest documents arrive, and can you prove what was sent?
- Have you answered every BVA question, including questions about relatives?
- Are there discrepancies in names, dates, relationships, translations or civil-status records?
- Are the residential and correspondence addresses current?
- Do you know which checks are ongoing and what information is still awaited?
The law provides for the involvement of security authorities. Section 28 BVFG governs this in the admission procedure; section 15(1) contains a corresponding rule, subject to its conditions, before certification. These provisions do not themselves prove that a security check is the reason your particular case is delayed. Section 28 BVFG and section 15 BVFG.
Whether a reason is sufficient is a legal question. The Federal Administrative Court has stated that sufficient justification must be consistent with the legal order. In a property dispute, waiting for a future legislative change did not justify delaying a decision. This offers general guidance; it was not a ruling on BVA processing periods for Spätaussiedler. BVerwG, 7 B 58.03, order of 8 January 2004.
One family’s lengthy wait does not establish that the entire programme has stopped. If the authority has not explained the delay, do not fill the gap with assumptions about bans, sanctions or “special lists”.
Status enquiries and complaints before court
Sachstandsanfrage: a status enquiry
A status enquiry helps establish facts. Identify the applicant, case reference, exact decision awaited, application date and date of your latest response to the BVA. Ask whether the documents have arrived, which evidence remains missing and what prevents a decision.
One structured letter with an attachment list is generally easier to review later than several messages containing scattered explanations. Keep the version sent together with delivery evidence.
Fristsetzung: requesting a response by a specified date
A written request for a decision or substantive response within a stated period may record your position and help a lawyer prepare the next step. A deadline you set does not bind the court merely because it appears in your letter.
Section 75 does not universally require a “final warning” followed by another mandatory 14- or 30-day wait. Sensible preparation before litigation should not be confused with an additional statutory condition. Section 75 VwGO.
Fachaufsichtsbeschwerde: a supervisory complaint
A supervisory complaint addresses the legality and appropriateness of the authority’s conduct. It may prompt a review of how the case is being handled, but it does not replace judicial protection or suspend deadlines for legal remedies. If a refusal has arrived, its instructions on remedies and timely next steps require separate review. Official information from Service-BW.
What can an action for failure to act achieve?
The claim must be correctly formulated. It may seek issuance of the requested document or a decision reflecting the court’s legal assessment. Under section 113(5) VwGO, the applicant’s entitlement and whether the case is ready for determination matter. A lengthy wait does not replace the conditions for an admission decision or certificate. Section 113(5) VwGO.
The substance of the file should therefore be reviewed before proceedings. A lawsuit does not remove serious contradictions in the evidence. If the BVA refuses the application during the case, send the decision to your lawyer immediately. The next step depends on the procedural position; any response from the authority does not automatically mean the case has been won.
If the wait creates a substantiated risk of significant harm, interim protection under section 123 VwGO may be considered separately. Both entitlement and urgency must be substantiated. Interim proceedings do not replace the main case or guarantee a document. Section 123 VwGO.
Court proceedings also take time. Promises that a document will arrive “within a few weeks of suing” create false expectations without a case-specific assessment.
Which court is responsible, and what does it cost?
These disputes are heard by administrative courts. For decisions of a federal authority, the general territorial rule points to the authority’s seat; Cologne Administrative Court is the usual starting point for BVA cases. The precise claim, defendant and jurisdiction must be checked before filing. Section 52 no. 2 VwGO and the Federal Office of Administration.
The defendant is normally the Federal Republic of Germany, represented by the BVA, not an individual caseworker. Section 78 VwGO.
Parties may represent themselves at first instance before the administrative court under section 67(1). The absence of compulsory representation does not make a universal template safe: errors in the claim, evidence or procedural steps can affect both outcome and costs. Section 67 VwGO.
There is no single price for “a lawsuit against the BVA”. Court fees depend, among other things, on the value in dispute (Streitwert), while the lawyer’s fee must be clarified separately. Before instructing a lawyer, request a written explanation of included work, possible extras and the cost implications of any later appeal. Section 52 of the Court Costs Act.
The unsuccessful party generally bears the costs. Specific rules apply when proceedings brought because of inaction are concluded, including section 161(3). Reimbursement cannot be promised solely because three months have passed. Section 154 VwGO and section 161 VwGO.
Documents to prepare for your lawyer
Assemble one indexed file containing:
- The application, every attachment and evidence of receipt by the BVA.
- The case-reference confirmation, the authority’s requests and your replies.
- For a post-entry case: admission decision, family-inclusion documents, registration certificate from Friedland (Registrierschein) and local residence registration.
- A separate list of family members and the document each is awaiting.
- A concise chronology: date, action, document and dispatch or receipt evidence.
- Letters explaining delays, complaints already submitted and decisions received.
- Evidence of specific consequences if the delay has created an urgent problem.
Do not omit inconvenient letters or earlier document versions. Your lawyer needs the complete picture, including questions not yet answered. Mark missing evidence explicitly rather than reconstructing a date from memory.
How Relocation DE can help
Relocation DE helps organise documents, the procedural chronology and BVA correspondence, and coordinate handover to a German lawyer. Legal assessment of litigation prospects and representation in court should be agreed separately with that lawyer.
When contacting us, explain whether you are awaiting an admission decision or a certificate after Friedland, when the relevant procedure began and when the BVA last requested documents. See our Spätaussiedler programme page or the Relocation DE website for further information.
Frequently asked questions
An action under section 75 can generally be considered after three months. The proper prior application, requested relief and reasons for the missing decision must be checked. Time alone does not guarantee success.
No. Section 75 concerns judicial protection against delayed processing. Entitlement to an admission decision or certificate depends on BVFG requirements and the evidence in the particular case.
Not automatically. Certification has its own procedure. Legally relevant events and dates must be established from the file. The previous wait for an admission decision does not transfer mechanically.
There is no universal automatic restart rule. Completeness of the earlier application, the need for new evidence and the requested decision matter. The lawyer therefore needs the original application, request and reply.
Section 75 does not require a prior supervisory complaint or a universal 14-day warning. A status enquiry can clarify facts; the strategy depends on the file.
Section 67(1) permits self-representation at first instance. For a dispute about status and certification, legal requirements, jurisdiction and costs should nevertheless be reviewed with a lawyer beforehand.
No. The court needs time, reasons for delay must be evaluated and document requirements must be met. Costs depend on the applicable rules and how proceedings develop.
This article provides general information, not individual legal advice. The original article records 6 October 2026 as its legal-source review date. Before taking procedural steps, check current legislation and your own case documents.